Ways to Select the Best Type of Metal

When it comes to choosing the right metal for your project, a systematic approach can save you money and time and ensure the success of your endeavor. Here are three essential steps to guide you through the process:

Define Your Project Requirements 

The first step in selecting the best type of metal is clearly defining your project’s specific requirements. Consider the following factors:

• Functionality

What role will the metal component play in your project? Is it for structural support, electrical conductivity, heat resistance, or something else entirely? Understanding its function is crucial.

• Environmental Conditions

Will the metal be exposed to harsh weather, chemicals, or high temperatures? Different metals have varying levels of corrosion resistance and heat tolerance.

• Strength and Durability

Assess the metal component’s load-bearing capacity and expected lifespan. Some metals, like steel, are renowned for their strength, while others may be more prone to deformation or wear.

• Budget

Determine your budget constraints. Some metals are more expensive than others, so balancing performance with cost is essential.

Research and Compare Metals 

Once you have a clear understanding of your project requirements, research and compare different types of metals and consider these factors:

• Material Properties

Examine various metals’ physical and chemical properties, such as tensile strength, conductivity, malleability, and corrosion resistance. Match these properties with your project’s needs.

• Availability

Ensure that the selected metal is readily available in the required form and quantity. Some specialized metals may be challenging to source.

• Environmental Influence

Assess the environmental impact of the metal. Is it recyclable? How energy-intensive is its production? Consider sustainability concerns.

• Testing and Prototyping

Conduct tests or create prototypes to validate the suitability of the chosen metal for your project. This step can help uncover potential issues early in the process.

Seek Expert Advice 

While you may have gathered valuable information during your research, consulting with metallurgy, engineering, or materials science experts can provide critical insights. Here’s how experts can assist:

• Expertise

Professionals in the field can offer expert guidance based on their extensive knowledge of materials and their real-world applications.

• Optimization

Experts can help optimize your choice, ensuring that the selected metal aligns perfectly with your project’s performance, cost-effectiveness, and longevity goals.

• Risk Mitigation

Professionals can identify potential risks or drawbacks associated with specific metals and suggest mitigation strategies.

Contact Markham Metals For Any Metal Services In New England

The process of selecting the best type of metal involves an evaluation of project requirements, metal comparison and expert advice. Making an informed choice is important to the success and longevity of your project. Consulting with Markham Metals is the next step! Our expert metal fabricators have many years of experience helping people pick the best metal for their projects. We are located in Wilmington, Massachusetts, but we serve all areas of New England. Contact us here today for a free quote on your next metal project. We look forward to hearing from you!

Q235 and Q345 are 16 Mn steel grade with good formability and weldability properties. It’s commonly used for structural applications and parts for a variety of industries. Q345 offers better performance at low temperatures and offers better steel strength.

Hot rolled steel is produced when steel is processed by a series of roll presses at temperatures over 1700°F. The process creates a steel that is easily formed or shaped into large pieces and is best used where tolerances aren’t as important.

Sheet metal is made from a variety of metals that each have their own unique properties and offer unique benefits. A list of the most common sheet metal materials used for fabrication have been summarized below.

The sheet metal used in your sheet meetal fabrication includes a very broad list of possible materials . Making the best choice for your products includes decisions about the type of metal, its thickness, and a choice of form. What you choose should be based on your overall expectations, desired end product, and recommendations from your sheet metal fabricator contractor manufacturing services

Section 3

Cold Rolled Steel (CRS)

Cold rolled steel (CRS) is essentially hot rolled steel that has gone through an additional rolling process at room temperature.

This additional processing produces a steel with closer tolerances and a broader range of finishes. The result is an increase in strength by as much as 20% compared to hot rolled steel. SPCC is commonly used for automotive parts and some construction applications. SPCC can be used for galvanized products, appliances, containers, and other products.

SAPH440 is commonly used for automotive frames, wheels, and other parts. It has very good tensile strength making it a good choice for load bearing or structural uses.

Advantages:

• Harder and stronger than hot rolled steel
• Good for tight tolerances, creating shapes that are square with true edges and corners
• Allows for precise dimensions
• High quality smooth surface and finish
• Easier to process than hot rolled steel with less spring back during bending
• Stable mechanical performance across multiple batches
• High formability

Disadvantages:

• Additional steps required after production to prevent corrosion
• Higher cost than hot rolled steel
• Cold rolled steel can be more expensive than hot rolled steel
• Only available up to 3 mm (0.12 inches) thick

Commonly used for:

• Machine and automotive parts
• Metal furniture, desks, cabinets
• Home appliances
• Lighting fixtures
• Construction products
• Steel drums, cabinetry, water heaters
• Strips, bars, and rods

Section 4

Spring Steel

The category of spring steel includes several high yield strength steels including low-alloy manganese, medium-carbon steel, or high-carbon steel. They are primarily used to manufacture springs as the steel will return to its original shape after twisting or load bearing.

A carbon steel can be used for small springs, but large springs are best when an alloy is used. High carbon spring steel is a common choice, inexpensive, and easily processed. It is not suited to extreme temperatures or for shock/ impact loads. Alloy spring steel are well suited to shock or impact loads or conditions with high stress. Stainless spring steel can be used in some forms at extremely high temperatures (288°C) and are corrosion resistant. 65Mn is a high carbon with manganese to improve hardenability. It has good wear resistance and good workability.

Advantages

• High yield strength, resistingdistortion when twisted or compressed
• Products can withstand continuous twisting, compression etc and return to original shape
• Good hardness, elasticity, and hardenability

Disadvantages

• Some metals can have issues when overheated including brittleness
• Requires tempering after heating and quenching to relieve material stresses
• Not all are well suited to welding
• Difficult to form in hardened and tempered state

Commonly used for:

• Valve springs
• Clutch springs, brake springs
• Grinder spindles
• Coil springs, leaf springs, and s-tines
• Piano wire, guitar strings, precision tool wires
• Washers
• Lock picks
• Antennas, scrapers
• Blades

Section 5

Aluminum

Aluminum is a pure metal that is easily alloyed with small amounts of other materials like copper, manganese, silicone, or magnesium. It is not magnetic or combustible and is a good conductor of electricity. Aluminum offers good corrosion resistance and is generally easy to form and process. It comes in several different grades and is often used because of its weight. It weighs about 1/3 of other materials like iron, steel, copper, and brass. It conducts heat well and is non-toxic making it a good choice in a variety of applications.

AL1060 is a wrought alloy with high electrical conductivity, corrosion resistance, and workability but somewhat low mechanical strength. It’s commonly used in electrical and chemical industries. AL6063 is most often used for architectural applications or trimming. It has high tensile properties and offers good finish options. It also offers high corrosion resistance and is a good option for anodized applications. AL 6061 is the most flexible heat-treated alloy with excellent workability. It’s well suited to most processes and has good corrosion resistance. AL 5052 is the highest strength non-heat-treated aluminum alloy and offers very good fatigue resistance. Highly workable, AL 5052 can be formed into complex shapes and offers good saltwater corrosion resistance.

Advantages

• Corrosion resistant and generally offers a maintenance-free finish
• Much lighter weight than alternatives like iron, steel, copper, and brass
• Great heat conductivity
• Nontoxic so it’s suitable for food exposure and other specialized applications
• Non-combustible and reflective so often used for lighting
• Good formability, workability, weldability and machineability

Disadvantages

• More expensive than steel
• Steel is a better option where strength is a primary concern and weight isn’t an issue
• Some alloys are less corrosion resistant than a stainless steel option
• Can affect taste of food so it’s less common for food or cooking applications

Commonly used for:

• Window frames
• Aircraft and automotive parts
• Kitchenware
• Food packaging
• Lighting
• Electrical products
• Machinery and equipment

Section 6

Stainless Steel

Stainless steel includes a variety of sheet metals which contain at least 10.5% chromium. There are many different grades available, offering corrosion resistant and a commercially familiar appearance. Standard or austenitic stainless steel (300 series steels) is very common and does not require heat during the manufacturing process. They offer good corrosion resistance, formability, and weldability.

SS301 has high work hardening and is commonly used for trailer bodies and fasteners. SS304 has low carbon, is an economical grade but is not seawater resistant. SS316 has higher molybdenum content that improves its resistance to seawater corrosion. A lower carbon version (SS316L) is available for better corrosion resistance after welding.

Advantages

• Chromium content creates a corrosion resistant finish
• Good combination of strength and hardness
• Available in a variety of widths, thickness, and hardness levels
• Can be used for hot or cold treatments/ processes
• Suitable for a variety of processing techniques including spinning, brazing, polishing, buffing
• Weldable and suitable for soldering or riveting processes
• Very machinable
• Recyclable

Disadvantages

• Can have corrosion at thick welding points
• Possible chipping during processing
• Tends to be more expensive
• Shows dirt and smudges easily and sometimes difficult to clean
• May require polishing and finishing

Commonly used for:

• Construction products like roofing, cladding, building structures, doors and windows
• Food processing equipment, cookware, and appliances
• Cooking utensils, kitchen sinks
• Vehicles including subways, cars airplanes
• Fuel and chemical containers

Section 7

Cold Galvanized Steel

Cold galvanized steel has a zinc coating painted to the steel surface to protect it from corrosion. The coating will provide both a barrier protection and a galvanic protection to help extend the life of the product. It can be applied with brushes, rollers, sprayers, or through electro galvanizing. The paint includes special binders so it will mechanically bond to the steel. SGCCis a galvanized steel with good weldability and formability. It can have a pure zinc coating or have a Zn/Fe alloy coating.

Advantages

• Protection in corrosive environments with a barrier and potentially cathodic protection for the steel
• Surfaces are generally easy to clean
• Low maintenance and good life expectancy for finished product
• Cost effective, fast application process
• Better than hot-dipped galvanization for small parts and components
• Can topcoat without any additional preparation

Disasdvantages

• Surface of the steel must be clean and dry before application. This requires an extra step but is less demanding than hot-dipped applications
• Doesn’t offer as good durability, abrasion resistance, or cathodic protection as hot-dipped galvanizing
• Physical damage can compromise the coating and result in corrosion
• Surface can include spangles

Commonly used for:

• Roofing, shutters, and other covers
• Equipment bodies

Section 8

Factors to Consider When Choosing Sheet Metal Material for Fabrication

Each metal has its own unique characteristics. This section of our guide outlines some of the factors that you should consider when making your choice of materials.

Surface finish Yield Tensile Hardness GB Standard   Powder coating E-coating Zinc plating Dacromet Anodized Passivation         Cold Rolled Steel (CRS)                     SPCC X X X X     ≥210MPa ≥350MPa HB 65 - 85 JIS G3141-2009 SAPH440 X X X X     ≥305MPa ≥440MPa HB 80 ±30 Q/BQB 310-2009 Hot Rolled Steel                     Q235 X X X X     ≥235MPa 375 ~500MPa HB 120 ±40 GB/T 700-2006 Q345 X X X X     ≥345MPa 490 ~675MPa HB 120 ±40 GB/T 1591-2008 Spring Steel                     65Mn X X         ≥785MPa ≥980MPa HB 190 - 340 GB/T 1222-2007 Aluminium                     AL 1060 X       X   ≥35MPa ≥75MPa HB 26 ±5 GB/T 3190-2008 AL6061 T6 X       X   ≥276MPa ≥260MPa HV 15 ~ 18 GB/T 3190-2008 AL6063 T5 X       X   ≥170MPa ≥250MPa HB 25 ±5 GB/T 3190-2008 AL5052 H32 X       X   ≥70MPa 210 ~ 260MPa HV 11 ±2 GB/T 3190-2008 Stainless                     SS301 X         X ≥205MPa ≥520MPa HB 76 ~ 187 GB/T 8170-2008 SS304 X         X ≥205MPa ≥520MPa HB 76 ~ 187 GB/T 24511-2009 SS316 X         X ≥205MPa ≥520MPa HB 76 ~ 187 GB/T 24511-2009 Cold Galvanized Steel                     SGCC X           ≥200MPa ≥380MPa HB 50 - 65 JIS-G3302

Section 9

Surface Finish Options

Different metals can accommodate different surface finishes. Some will require additional processing before a surface finish can be applied. Your choice of surface finishes can be for aesthetic or functional reasons – or both.

• Powder coating is a dry powder used in place of traditional liquid paint. Applied electrostatically and heat cured, it provides a harder and more durable finish than traditional paint. The coating is often thicker, creates a more uniform finish with no drips or running, and can allow for some unique finishing. The powder coating material has no solvents and a fast-curing time. Powder coating is available for most metals including: hot rolled steel, cold rolled steel, aluminum, stainless steel, spring steel, and cold galvanized steel.
• E-coating (electrophoretic painting) coats the metal parts by way of a bath that includes paint, resins, or pigments in a water-based solution. The use of an electric current facilitates the deposit of particles on the metal surface. The electric voltage can be adjusted to increase the thickness of the coating. Heat is applied to cure the e-coating. E-coating can be applied as a primer for further finishing or on its own to help prevent corrosion. Its commonly used on hot rolled, cold rolled, and spring steel.
• Zinc plating uses electrolysis to apply zinc to the surface. The result is a fine coating appropriate for detailed surfaces but less suited to heavy-duty applications. The zinc plating protects the metal from corrosion in 2 ways: as a physical barrier and as a sacrificial anode because it will corrode instead of the steel its applied to. Zinc coating is used for hot rolled and cold rolled steel to produce a product with high strength, good formability and corrosion resistant.
• Dacromet is a brand of coating that uses zinc and aluminum flakes combined with a binder for cold-dipped or spray applications followed by the application of heat. It offers corrosion and barrier protection and is a form of passivation. The result is improved resistance to organic solvents, heat, and salt. The coating is also conductive. Dacromet is common for hot rolled and cold rolled steel.
• Anodizing is used to improve the corrosion and wear resistance of aluminum alloys. While aluminum itself is very corrosion resistant, not all metals used in aluminum alloys are. The anodizing processes submerges the material into an electrolytic, acid solution that forms an aluminum oxide layer on the surface of the metal. Anodizing is common for aluminum alloys used in marine or saltwater environments to prevent corrosion. It’s also used to improve the hardness of aluminum as the harder aluminum oxide provides additional abrasion resistance.
• Passivation reduces the natural chemical reactivity of the metal’s surface. In the case of stainless steel, an acid solution is applied to remove any free iron from the surface leaving behind elements that are more resistant to rust and corrosion. Surface damage to the metal can expose iron in the material resulting in corrosion. As a result, passivation many need to occur more than once throughout the lifecycle of a product.

Section 10

Yield Strength

The yield strength of a metal is the point at which applied stress will cause it to deform and not return to its original shape. It provides an indication of a metal’s elasticity and the maximum force you can apply to it before it will permanently deform, buckle, or even fail. Processes like annealing can impact the yield strength of some materials.

• High yield strength metals: spring steel, cold galvanized steel, cold rolled steel, hot rolled steel, titanium, stainless steel, aluminum alloys
• Low yield strength metals: copper, brass, some aluminum alloys

Section 11

Hardness

Hardness refers to the metal’s ability to resist deformation from an impact, abrasion, or load. You can measure hardness based on its resistance to scratches, indentations, or rebounds. Some issues with hardness can be overcome with a hardening process. Hardness is important for load bearing structures as hard metals are better able to withstand the application of load or abrasion.

• High hardness metals: spring steel, hot rolled steel, titanium, stainless steel, cast iron, bronze, brass
• Low hardness metals: aluminum, copper, lead

Section 12

Tensile Strength

Tensile strength refers to ability of a metal to resist force. Higher tensile strength requires more force to snap it for example. If the product you’re producing doesn’t need to bear any load, then a metal with less tensile strength might be the best choice. Keep in mind that how you form the sheet metal can impact its strength and the load it can bear.

• High tensile strength metals: spring steel, hot rolled steel, cold rolled steel, cold galvanized steel, stainless steel, titanium
• Low tensile strength metals: aluminum

Section 13

Ductility or Formability

The ductility of a metal offers insight into how pliable it is and how easy it is to form. When a metal is referred to as having high ductility, that means it easier to form and bend.

• High ductility metals: aluminum, high carbon steel, brass, copper
• Low ductility metals: stainless steel, low carbon steel, medium carbon steel (medium)

Section 14

Weldability

If your product requires welding, it’s important to understand how easy or difficult a metal is to weld. Some metals require extensive preparation or advanced welding techniques which can impact both your budget and schedule.

• Easily weldable metals:cold-rolled steel, low carbon steel
• Less weldable metals: aluminum, copper,stainless steel (medium), high carbon steel

Section 15

Machinability

A metal that has high machinability is one that can be more easily cut and cut at higher speeds. Hard machinability requires more power and time to cut the metal.

• Hard machinability metals: stainless steel
• Low/ medium machinability metals: steel, aluminum

Section 16

Corrosion Resistance

The material you choose should take into consideration the environment it will be exposed to. Some metals respond better than others to factors like water, oxidation, or other elements it will be exposed to. Some metals, like stainless steel, won’t corrode but they can develop an oxide film. Also keep in mind that galvanic corrosion can occur when to dissimilar metals are in contact with each other.

• Less corrosion resistant metals: cold-rolled carbon steel
• More corrosion resistant metals: copper, stainless steel, aluminum, nickel, titanium, tin

Section 17

Weight

Choosing a lighter weight material might be best for large objects or objects that need to move (like vehicles, trailers, etc.). At the same time, you need to consider the strength of the material. In general, lighter metals have less strength than heavier ones – although that’s not always the case.

• Lightweight metals: aluminum, titanium
• Heavier metals: copper, brass, steel, stainless steel

Section 18

Cost

Cost usually isn’t’ the most important factor in choosing a sheet metal for fabrication. It’s important to make the best choice based on the other factors we’ve listed. However, if there is an equally good alternative that has a lower cost, it’s worth considering. Keep in mind however, sometimes lower cost materials require additional processing which may result in you not actually saving a lot had you used the higher cost material instead.

• High-cost metals: stainless steel
• Low-cost metals: low carbon steel, hot rolled steel, tin

Our team of engineers and technicians here at Komaspec have more than 15-years’ experience in sheet metal fabrication in China and are glad to review your product design together and help you select the fabrication process that best suits your product’s needs, whether it’s laser cutting, bending, stamping, etc..