Your Position: Home - Energy - What is the most efficient form of energy storage?
The Llyn Stwlan dam of the Ffestiniog Pumped Storage Scheme in Wales. The lower power station has four water turbines which can generate a total of 360 MW of electricity for several hours, an example of artificial energy storage and conversion.
Energy storage is the capture of energy produced at one time for use at a later time[1] to reduce imbalances between energy demand and energy production. A device that stores energy is generally called an accumulator or battery. Energy comes in multiple forms including radiation, chemical, gravitational potential, electrical potential, electricity, elevated temperature, latent heat and kinetic. Energy storage involves converting energy from forms that are difficult to store to more conveniently or economically storable forms.
Some technologies provide short-term energy storage, while others can endure for much longer. Bulk energy storage is currently dominated by hydroelectric dams, both conventional as well as pumped. Grid energy storage is a collection of methods used for energy storage on a large scale within an electrical power grid.
Common examples of energy storage are the rechargeable battery, which stores chemical energy readily convertible to electricity to operate a mobile phone; the hydroelectric dam, which stores energy in a reservoir as gravitational potential energy; and ice storage tanks, which store ice frozen by cheaper energy at night to meet peak daytime demand for cooling. Green hydrogen, from the electrolysis of water, is a more economical means of long-term renewable energy storage in terms of capital expenditures than pumped-storage hydroelectricity or batteries.[citation needed][2][failed verification][3][failed verification] Fossil fuels such as coal and gasoline store ancient energy derived from sunlight by organisms that later died, became buried and over time were then converted into these fuels. Food (which is made by the same process as fossil fuels) is a form of energy stored in chemical form.
History
[
edit
]
In the 20th century grid, electrical power was largely generated by burning fossil fuel. When less power was required, less fuel was burned.[4] Hydropower, a mechanical energy storage method, is the most widely adopted mechanical energy storage, and has been in use for centuries. Large hydropower dams have been energy storage sites for more than one hundred years.[5] Concerns with air pollution, energy imports, and global warming have spawned the growth of renewable energy such as solar and wind power.[4] Wind power is uncontrolled and may be generating at a time when no additional power is needed. Solar power varies with cloud cover and at best is only available during daylight hours, while demand often peaks after sunset (see duck curve). Interest in storing power from these intermittent sources grows as the renewable energy industry begins to generate a larger fraction of overall energy consumption.[6]
Off grid electrical use was a niche market in the 20th century, but in the 21st century, it has expanded. Portable devices are in use all over the world. Solar panels are now common in the rural settings worldwide. Access to electricity is now a question of economics and financial viability, and not solely on technical aspects. Electric vehicles are gradually replacing combustion-engine vehicles. However, powering long-distance transportation without burning fuel remains in development.
Methods
[
edit
]
Comparison of various energy storage technologiesOutline
[
edit
]
The following list includes a variety of types of energy storage:
Mechanical
[
edit
]
Energy can be stored in water pumped to a higher elevation using pumped storage methods or by moving solid matter to higher locations (gravity batteries). Other commercial mechanical methods include compressing air and flywheels that convert electric energy into internal energy or kinetic energy and then back again when electrical demand peaks.
Hydroelectricity
[
edit
]
Hydroelectric dams with reservoirs can be operated to provide electricity at times of peak demand. Water is stored in the reservoir during periods of low demand and released when demand is high. The net effect is similar to pumped storage, but without the pumping loss.
While a hydroelectric dam does not directly store energy from other generating units, it behaves equivalently by lowering output in periods of excess electricity from other sources. In this mode, dams are one of the most efficient forms of energy storage, because only the timing of its generation changes. Hydroelectric turbines have a start-up time on the order of a few minutes.[7]
Pumped hydro
[
edit
]
Worldwide, pumped-storage hydroelectricity (PSH) is the largest-capacity form of active grid energy storage available, and, as of March 2012, the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) reports that PSH accounts for more than 99% of bulk storage capacity worldwide, representing around 127,000 MW.[8] PSH energy efficiency varies in practice between 70% and 80%,[8][9][10][11] with claims of up to 87%.[12]
At times of low electrical demand, excess generation capacity is used to pump water from a lower source into a higher reservoir. When demand grows, water is released back into a lower reservoir (or waterway or body of water) through a turbine, generating electricity. Reversible turbine-generator assemblies act as both a pump and turbine (usually a Francis turbine design). Nearly all facilities use the height difference between two water bodies. Pure pumped-storage plants shift the water between reservoirs, while the "pump-back" approach is a combination of pumped storage and conventional hydroelectric plants that use natural stream-flow.
Compressed air
[
edit
]
A compressed air locomotive used inside a mine between 1928 and 1961.Compressed air energy storage (CAES) uses surplus energy to compress air for subsequent electricity generation.[13] Small-scale systems have long been used in such applications as propulsion of mine locomotives. The compressed air is stored in an underground reservoir, such as a salt dome.
Compressed-air energy storage (CAES) plants can bridge the gap between production volatility and load. CAES storage addresses the energy needs of consumers by effectively providing readily available energy to meet demand. Renewable energy sources like wind and solar energy vary. So at times when they provide little power, they need to be supplemented with other forms of energy to meet energy demand. Compressed-air energy storage plants can take in the surplus energy output of renewable energy sources during times of energy over-production. This stored energy can be used at a later time when demand for electricity increases or energy resource availability decreases.[14]
Compression of air creates heat; the air is warmer after compression. Expansion requires heat. If no extra heat is added, the air will be much colder after expansion. If the heat generated during compression can be stored and used during expansion, efficiency improves considerably.[15] A CAES system can deal with the heat in three ways. Air storage can be adiabatic, diabatic, or isothermal. Another approach uses compressed air to power vehicles.[16][17]
Flywheel
[
edit
]
The main components of a typical flywheel.Flywheel energy storage (FES) works by accelerating a rotor (a flywheel) to a very high speed, holding energy as rotational energy. When energy is added the rotational speed of the flywheel increases, and when energy is extracted, the speed declines, due to conservation of energy.
Most FES systems use electricity to accelerate and decelerate the flywheel, but devices that directly use mechanical energy are under consideration.[18]
FES systems have rotors made of high strength carbon-fiber composites, suspended by magnetic bearings and spinning at speeds from 20,000 to over 50,000 revolutions per minute (rpm) in a vacuum enclosure.[19] Such flywheels can reach maximum speed ("charge") in a matter of minutes. The flywheel system is connected to a combination electric motor/generator.
FES systems have relatively long lifetimes (lasting decades with little or no maintenance;[19] full-cycle lifetimes quoted for flywheels range from in excess of 105, up to 107, cycles of use),[20] high specific energy (100–130 W·h/kg, or 360–500 kJ/kg)[20][21] and power density.
Solid mass gravitational
[
edit
]
Changing the altitude of solid masses can store or release energy via an elevating system driven by an electric motor/generator. Studies suggest energy can begin to be released with as little as 1 second warning, making the method a useful supplemental feed into an electricity grid to balance load surges.[22]
Efficiencies can be as high as 85% recovery of stored energy.[23]
This can be achieved by siting the masses inside old vertical mine shafts or in specially constructed towers where the heavy weights are winched up to store energy and allowed a controlled descent to release it. At 2020 a prototype vertical store is being built in Edinburgh, Scotland [24]
Potential energy storage or gravity energy storage was under active development in 2013 in association with the California Independent System Operator.[25][26][27] It examined the movement of earth-filled hopper rail cars driven by electric locomotives from lower to higher elevations.[28]
Other proposed methods include:-
Thermal
[
edit
]
Thermal energy storage (TES) is the temporary storage or removal of heat.
Sensible heat thermal
[
edit
]
Sensible heat storage take advantage of sensible heat in a material to store energy.[33]
Seasonal thermal energy storage (STES) allows heat or cold to be used months after it was collected from waste energy or natural sources. The material can be stored in contained aquifers, clusters of boreholes in geological substrates such as sand or crystalline bedrock, in lined pits filled with gravel and water, or water-filled mines.[34] Seasonal thermal energy storage (STES) projects often have paybacks in four to six years.[35] An example is Drake Landing Solar Community in Canada, for which 97% of the year-round heat is provided by solar-thermal collectors on garage roofs, enabled by a borehole thermal energy store (BTES).[36][37][38] In Braedstrup, Denmark, the community's solar district heating system also uses STES, at a temperature of 65 °C (149 °F). A heat pump, which runs only while surplus wind power is available. It is used to raise the temperature to 80 °C (176 °F) for distribution. When wind energy is not available, a gas-fired boiler is used. Twenty percent of Braedstrup's heat is solar.[39]
Latent heat thermal (LHTES)[
edit
]
Latent heat thermal energy storage systems work by transferring heat to or from a material to change its phase. A phase-change is the melting, solidifying, vaporizing or liquifying. Such a material is called a phase change material (PCM). Materials used in LHTESs often have a high latent heat so that at their specific temperature, the phase change absorbs a large amount of energy, much more than sensible heat.[40]
A steam accumulator is a type of LHTES where the phase change is between liquid and gas and uses the latent heat of vaporization of water. Ice storage air conditioning systems use off-peak electricity to store cold by freezing water into ice. The stored cold in ice releases during melting process and can be used for cooling at peak hours.
Cryogenic thermal energy storage
[
edit
]
Air can be liquefied by cooling using electricity and stored as a cryogen with existing technologies. The liquid air can then be expanded through a turbine and the energy recovered as electricity. The system was demonstrated at a pilot plant in the UK in 2012.[41] In 2019, Highview announced plans to build a 50 MW in the North of England and northern Vermont, with the proposed facility able to store five to eight hours of energy, for a 250-400 MWh storage capacity.[42]
Carnot battery
[
edit
]
Electrical energy can be stored thermally by resistive heating or heat pumps, and the stored heat can be converted back to electricity via Rankine cycle or Brayton cycle.[43] This technology has been studied to retrofit coal-fired power plants into fossil-fuel free generation systems.[44] Coal-fired boilers are replaced by high-temperature heat storage charged by excess electricity from renewable energy sources. In 2020, German Aerospace Center started to construct the world's first large-scale Carnot battery system, which has 1,000 MWh storage capacity.[45]
Electrochemical
[
edit
]
Rechargeable battery
[
edit
]
A rechargeable battery bank used as an uninterruptible power supply in a data centerA rechargeable battery comprises one or more electrochemical cells. It is known as a 'secondary cell' because its electrochemical reactions are electrically reversible. Rechargeable batteries come in many shapes and sizes, ranging from button cells to megawatt grid systems.
Rechargeable batteries have lower total cost of use and environmental impact than non-rechargeable (disposable) batteries. Some rechargeable battery types are available in the same form factors as disposables. Rechargeable batteries have higher initial cost but can be recharged very cheaply and used many times.
Common rechargeable battery chemistries include:
Flow battery
[
edit
]
A flow battery works by passing a solution over a membrane where ions are exchanged to charge or discharge the cell. Cell voltage is chemically determined by the Nernst equation and ranges, in practical applications, from 1.0 V to 2.2 V. Storage capacity depends on the volume of solution. A flow battery is technically akin both to a fuel cell and an electrochemical accumulator cell. Commercial applications are for long half-cycle storage such as backup grid power.
Supercapacitor
[
edit
]
One of a fleet of electric capabuses powered by supercapacitors, at a quick-charge station-bus stop, in service during Expo 2010 Shanghai China. Charging rails can be seen suspended over the bus.Supercapacitors, also called electric double-layer capacitors (EDLC) or ultracapacitors, are a family of electrochemical capacitors[49] that do not have conventional solid dielectrics. Capacitance is determined by two storage principles, double-layer capacitance and pseudocapacitance.[50][51]
Supercapacitors bridge the gap between conventional capacitors and rechargeable batteries. They store the most energy per unit volume or mass (energy density) among capacitors. They support up to 10,000 farads/1.2 Volt,[52] up to 10,000 times that of electrolytic capacitors, but deliver or accept less than half as much power per unit time (power density).[49]
While supercapacitors have specific energy and energy densities that are approximately 10% of batteries, their power density is generally 10 to 100 times greater. This results in much shorter charge/discharge cycles. Also, they tolerate many more charge-discharge cycles than batteries.
Supercapacitors have many applications, including:
Chemical
[
edit
]
Power to gas
[
edit
]
The new technology helps reduce greenhouse gases and operating costs at two existing peaker plants in Norwalk and Rancho Cucamonga. The 10-megawatt battery storage system, combined with the gas turbine, allows the peaker plant to more quickly respond to changing energy needs, thus increasing the reliability of the electrical grid.Power to gas is the conversion of electricity to a gaseous fuel such as hydrogen or methane. The three commercial methods use electricity to reduce water into hydrogen and oxygen by means of electrolysis.
In the first method, hydrogen is injected into the natural gas grid or is used for transportation. The second method is to combine the hydrogen with carbon dioxide to produce methane using a methanation reaction such as the Sabatier reaction, or biological methanation, resulting in an extra energy conversion loss of 8%. The methane may then be fed into the natural gas grid. The third method uses the output gas of a wood gas generator or a biogas plant, after the biogas upgrader is mixed with the hydrogen from the electrolyzer, to upgrade the quality of the biogas.
Hydrogen
[
edit
]
The element hydrogen can be a form of stored energy. Hydrogen can produce electricity via a hydrogen fuel cell. Green hydrogen, from electrolysis of water, is a more economical means of long-term renewable energy storage in terms of capital expenditures than pumped-storage hydroelectricity or batteries.[citation needed][2][failed verification][3][failed verification]
At penetrations below 20% of the grid demand, renewables do not severely change the economics; but beyond about 20% of the total demand,[53] external storage becomes important. If these sources are used to make ionic hydrogen, they can be freely expanded. A 5-year community-based pilot program using wind turbines and hydrogen generators began in 2007 in the remote community of Ramea, Newfoundland and Labrador.[54] A similar project began in 2004 on Utsira, a small Norwegian island.
Energy losses involved in the hydrogen storage cycle come from the electrolysis of water, liquification or compression of the hydrogen and conversion to electricity.[55]
About 50 kW·h (180 MJ) of solar energy is required to produce a kilogram of hydrogen, so the cost of the electricity is crucial. At $0.03/kWh, a common off-peak high-voltage line rate in the United States, hydrogen costs $1.50 per kilogram for the electricity, equivalent to $1.50/gallon for gasoline. Other costs include the electrolyzer plant, hydrogen compressors or liquefaction, storage and transportation.[citation needed]
Hydrogen can also be produced from aluminum and water by stripping aluminum's naturally-occurring aluminum oxide barrier and introducing it to water. This method is beneficial because recycled aluminum cans can be used to generate hydrogen, however systems to harness this option have not been commercially developed and are much more complex than electrolysis systems.[56] Common methods to strip the oxide layer include caustic catalysts such as sodium hydroxide and alloys with gallium, mercury and other metals.[57]
Underground hydrogen storage is the practice of hydrogen storage in caverns, salt domes and depleted oil and gas fields.[58][59] Large quantities of gaseous hydrogen have been stored in caverns by Imperial Chemical Industries for many years without any difficulties.[60] The European Hyunder project indicated in 2013 that storage of wind and solar energy using underground hydrogen would require 85 caverns.[61]
Powerpaste is a magnesium and hydrogen -based fluid gel that releases hydrogen when reacting with water. It was invented, patented and is being developed by the Fraunhofer Institute for Manufacturing Technology and Advanced Materials (IFAM) of the Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft. Powerpaste is made by combining magnesium powder with hydrogen to form magnesium hydride in a process conducted at 350 °C and five to six times atmospheric pressure. An ester and a metal salt are then added to make the finished product. Fraunhofer states that they are building a production plant slated to start production in 2021, which will produce 4 tons of Powerpaste annually.[62] Fraunhofer has patented their invention in the United States and EU.[63] Fraunhofer claims that Powerpaste is able to store hydrogen energy at 10 times the energy density of a lithium battery of a similar dimension and is safe and convenient for automotive situations.[62]
Methane
[
edit
]
Methane is the simplest hydrocarbon with the molecular formula CH4. Methane is more easily stored and transported than hydrogen. Storage and combustion infrastructure (pipelines, gasometers, power plants) are mature.
Synthetic natural gas (syngas or SNG) can be created in a multi-step process, starting with hydrogen and oxygen. Hydrogen is then reacted with carbon dioxide in a Sabatier process, producing methane and water. Methane can be stored and later used to produce electricity. The resulting water is recycled, reducing the need for water. In the electrolysis stage, oxygen is stored for methane combustion in a pure oxygen environment at an adjacent power plant, eliminating nitrogen oxides.
Methane combustion produces carbon dioxide (CO2) and water. The carbon dioxide can be recycled to boost the Sabatier process and water can be recycled for further electrolysis. Methane production, storage and combustion recycles the reaction products.
The CO2 has economic value as a component of an energy storage vector, not a cost as in carbon capture and storage.
Power to liquid
[
edit
]
Power to liquid is similar to power to gas except that the hydrogen is converted into liquids such as methanol or ammonia. These are easier to handle than gases, and require fewer safety precautions than hydrogen. They can be used for transportation, including aircraft, but also for industrial purposes or in the power sector.[64]
Biofuels
[
edit
]
Various biofuels such as biodiesel, vegetable oil, alcohol fuels, or biomass can replace fossil fuels. Various chemical processes can convert the carbon and hydrogen in coal, natural gas, plant and animal biomass and organic wastes into short hydrocarbons suitable as replacements for existing hydrocarbon fuels. Examples are Fischer–Tropsch diesel, methanol, dimethyl ether and syngas. This diesel source was used extensively in World War II in Germany, which faced limited access to crude oil supplies. South Africa produces most of the country's diesel from coal for similar reasons.[65] A long term oil price above US$35/bbl may make such large scale synthetic liquid fuels economical.
Aluminum
[
edit
]
Aluminum has been proposed as an energy store by a number of researchers. Its electrochemical equivalent (8.04 Ah/cm3) is nearly four times greater than that of lithium (2.06 Ah/cm3).[66] Energy can be extracted from aluminum by reacting it with water to generate hydrogen.[67] However, it must first be stripped of its natural oxide layer, a process which requires pulverization,[68] chemical reactions with caustic substances, or alloys.[57] The byproduct of the reaction to create hydrogen is aluminum oxide, which can be recycled into aluminum with the Hall–Héroult process, making the reaction theoretically renewable.[57] If the Hall-Heroult Process is run using solar or wind power, aluminum could be used to store the energy produced at higher efficiency than direct solar electrolysis.[69]
Boron, silicon, and zinc
[
edit
]
Boron,[70] silicon,[71] and zinc[72] have been proposed as energy storage solutions.
Other chemical
[
edit
]
The organic compound norbornadiene converts to quadricyclane upon exposure to light, storing solar energy as the energy of chemical bonds. A working system has been developed in Sweden as a molecular solar thermal system.[73]
Electrical methods
[
edit
]
Capacitor
[
edit
]
This mylar-film, oil-filled capacitor has very low inductance and low resistance, to provide the high-power (70 megawatts) and the very high speed (1.2 microsecond) discharges needed to operate a dye laser.A capacitor (originally known as a 'condenser') is a passive two-terminal electrical component used to store energy electrostatically. Practical capacitors vary widely, but all contain at least two electrical conductors (plates) separated by a dielectric (i.e., insulator). A capacitor can store electric energy when disconnected from its charging circuit, so it can be used like a temporary battery, or like other types of rechargeable energy storage system.[74] Capacitors are commonly used in electronic devices to maintain power supply while batteries change. (This prevents loss of information in volatile memory.) Conventional capacitors provide less than 360 joules per kilogram, while a conventional alkaline battery has a density of 590 kJ/kg.
Capacitors store energy in an electrostatic field between their plates. Given a potential difference across the conductors (e.g., when a capacitor is attached across a battery), an electric field develops across the dielectric, causing positive charge (+Q) to collect on one plate and negative charge (-Q) to collect on the other plate. If a battery is attached to a capacitor for a sufficient amount of time, no current can flow through the capacitor. However, if an accelerating or alternating voltage is applied across the leads of the capacitor, a displacement current can flow. Besides capacitor plates, charge can also be stored in a dielectric layer.[75]
Capacitance is greater given a narrower separation between conductors and when the conductors have a larger surface area. In practice, the dielectric between the plates emits a small amount of leakage current and has an electric field strength limit, known as the breakdown voltage. However, the effect of recovery of a dielectric after a high-voltage breakdown holds promise for a new generation of self-healing capacitors.[76][77] The conductors and leads introduce undesired inductance and resistance.
Research is assessing the quantum effects of nanoscale capacitors[78] for digital quantum batteries.[79][80]
Superconducting magnetics
[
edit
]
Superconducting magnetic energy storage (SMES) systems store energy in a magnetic field created by the flow of direct current in a superconducting coil that has been cooled to a temperature below its superconducting critical temperature. A typical SMES system includes a superconducting coil, power conditioning system and refrigerator. Once the superconducting coil is charged, the current does not decay and the magnetic energy can be stored indefinitely.[81]
The stored energy can be released to the network by discharging the coil. The associated inverter/rectifier accounts for about 2–3% energy loss in each direction. SMES loses the least amount of electricity in the energy storage process compared to other methods of storing energy. SMES systems offer round-trip efficiency greater than 95%.[82]
Due to the energy requirements of refrigeration and the cost of superconducting wire, SMES is used for short duration storage such as improving power quality. It also has applications in grid balancing.[81]
Applications
[
edit
]
Mills
[
edit
]
The classic application before the industrial revolution was the control of waterways to drive water mills for processing grain or powering machinery. Complex systems of reservoirs and dams were constructed to store and release water (and the potential energy it contained) when required.[83]
Homes
[
edit
]
Home energy storage is expected to become increasingly common given the growing importance of distributed generation of renewable energies (especially photovoltaics) and the important share of energy consumption in buildings.[84] To exceed a self-sufficiency of 40% in a household equipped with photovoltaics, energy storage is needed.[84] Multiple manufacturers produce rechargeable battery systems for storing energy, generally to hold surplus energy from home solar or wind generation. Today, for home energy storage, Li-ion batteries are preferable to lead-acid ones given their similar cost but much better performance.[85]
Tesla Motors produces two models of the Tesla Powerwall. One is a 10 kWh weekly cycle version for backup applications and the other is a 7 kWh version for daily cycle applications.[86] In 2016, a limited version of the Tesla Powerpack 2 cost $398(US)/kWh to store electricity worth 12.5 cents/kWh (US average grid price) making a positive return on investment doubtful unless electricity prices are higher than 30 cents/kWh.[87]
RoseWater Energy produces two models of the "Energy & Storage System", the HUB 120[88] and SB20.[89] Both versions provide 28.8 kWh of output, enabling it to run larger houses or light commercial premises, and protecting custom installations. The system provides five key elements into one system, including providing a clean 60 Hz Sine wave, zero transfer time, industrial-grade surge protection, renewable energy grid sell-back (optional), and battery backup.[90][91]
Enphase Energy announced an integrated system that allows home users to store, monitor and manage electricity. The system stores 1.2 kWh of energy and 275W/500W power output.[92]
Storing wind or solar energy using thermal energy storage though less flexible, is considerably cheaper than batteries. A simple 52-gallon electric water heater can store roughly 12 kWh of energy for supplementing hot water or space heating.[93]
For purely financial purposes in areas where net metering is available, home generated electricity may be sold to the grid through a grid-tie inverter without the use of batteries for storage.
Grid electricity and power stations
[
edit
]
Renewable energy
[
edit
]
Construction of the Salt Tanks which provide efficient thermal energy storage[94] so that electricity can be generated after the sun goes down, and output can be scheduled to meet demand.[95] The 280 MW Solana Generating Station is designed to provide six hours of storage. This allows the plant to generate about 38% of its rated capacity over the course of a year.[96]The largest source and the greatest store of renewable energy is provided by hydroelectric dams. A large reservoir behind a dam can store enough water to average the annual flow of a river between dry and wet seasons, and a very large reservoir can store enough water to average the flow of a river between dry and wet years. While a hydroelectric dam does not directly store energy from intermittent sources, it does balance the grid by lowering its output and retaining its water when power is generated by solar or wind. If wind or solar generation exceeds the region's hydroelectric capacity, then some additional source of energy is needed.
Many renewable energy sources (notably solar and wind) produce variable power.[98] Storage systems can level out the imbalances between supply and demand that this causes. Electricity must be used as it is generated or converted immediately into storable forms.[99]
The main method of electrical grid storage is pumped-storage hydroelectricity. Areas of the world such as Norway, Wales, Japan and the US have used elevated geographic features for reservoirs, using electrically powered pumps to fill them. When needed, the water passes through generators and converts the gravitational potential of the falling water into electricity.[98] Pumped storage in Norway, which gets almost all its electricity from hydro, has currently a capacity of 1.4 GW but since the total installed capacity is nearly 32 GW and 75% of that is regulable, it can be expanded significantly.[100]
Some forms of storage that produce electricity include pumped-storage hydroelectric dams, rechargeable batteries, thermal storage including molten salts which can efficiently store and release very large quantities of heat energy,[101] and compressed air energy storage, flywheels, cryogenic systems and superconducting magnetic coils.
Surplus power can also be converted into methane (sabatier process) with stockage in the natural gas network.[102][103]
In 2011, the Bonneville Power Administration in the northwestern United States created an experimental program to absorb excess wind and hydro power generated at night or during stormy periods that are accompanied by high winds. Under central control, home appliances absorb surplus energy by heating ceramic bricks in special space heaters to hundreds of degrees and by boosting the temperature of modified hot water heater tanks. After charging, the appliances provide home heating and hot water as needed. The experimental system was created as a result of a severe 2010 storm that overproduced renewable energy to the extent that all conventional power sources were shut down, or in the case of a nuclear power plant, reduced to its lowest possible operating level, leaving a large area running almost completely on renewable energy.[104][105]
Another advanced method used at the former Solar Two project in the United States and the Solar Tres Power Tower in Spain uses molten salt to store thermal energy captured from the sun and then convert it and dispatch it as electrical power. The system pumps molten salt through a tower or other special conduits to be heated by the sun. Insulated tanks store the solution. Electricity is produced by turning water to steam that is fed to turbines.
Since the early 21st century batteries have been applied to utility scale load-leveling and frequency regulation capabilities.[98]
In vehicle-to-grid storage, electric vehicles that are plugged into the energy grid can deliver stored electrical energy from their batteries into the grid when needed.
Air conditioning
[
edit
]
Thermal energy storage (TES) can be used for air conditioning.[106] It is most widely used for cooling single large buildings and/or groups of smaller buildings. Commercial air conditioning systems are the biggest contributors to peak electrical loads. In 2009, thermal storage was used in over 3,300 buildings in over 35 countries. It works by chilling material at night and using the chilled material for cooling during the hotter daytime periods.[101]
The most popular technique is ice storage, which requires less space than water and is cheaper than fuel cells or flywheels. In this application, a standard chiller runs at night to produce an ice pile. Water circulates through the pile during the day to chill water that would normally be the chiller's daytime output.
A partial storage system minimizes capital investment by running the chillers nearly 24 hours a day. At night, they produce ice for storage and during the day they chill water. Water circulating through the melting ice augments the production of chilled water. Such a system makes ice for 16 to 18 hours a day and melts ice for six hours a day. Capital expenditures are reduced because the chillers can be just 40% - 50% of the size needed for a conventional, no-storage design. Storage sufficient to store half a day's available heat is usually adequate.
A full storage system shuts off the chillers during peak load hours. Capital costs are higher, as such a system requires larger chillers and a larger ice storage system.
This ice is produced when electrical utility rates are lower.[107] Off-peak cooling systems can lower energy costs. The U.S. Green Building Council has developed the Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) program to encourage the design of reduced-environmental impact buildings. Off-peak cooling may help toward LEED Certification.[108]
Thermal storage for heating is less common than for cooling. An example of thermal storage is storing solar heat to be used for heating at night.
Latent heat can also be stored in technical phase change materials (PCMs). These can be encapsulated in wall and ceiling panels, to moderate room temperatures.
Transport
[
edit
]
Liquid hydrocarbon fuels are the most commonly used forms of energy storage for use in transportation, followed by a growing use of Battery Electric Vehicles and Hybrid Electric Vehicles. Other energy carriers such as hydrogen can be used to avoid producing greenhouse gases.
Public transport systems like trams and trolleybuses require electricity, but due to their variability in movement, a steady supply of electricity via renewable energy is challenging. Photovoltaic systems installed on the roofs of buildings can be used to power public transportation systems during periods in which there is increased demand for electricity and access to other forms of energy are not readily available.[109] Upcoming transitions in the transportation system also include e.g. ferries and airplanes, where electric power supply is investigated as an interesting alternative.[110]
Electronics
[
edit
]
Capacitors are widely used in electronic circuits for blocking direct current while allowing alternating current to pass. In analog filter networks, they smooth the output of power supplies. In resonant circuits they tune radios to particular frequencies. In electric power transmission systems they stabilize voltage and power flow.[111]
Use cases
[
edit
]
The United States Department of Energy International Energy Storage Database (IESDB), is a free-access database of energy storage projects and policies funded by the United States Department of Energy Office of Electricity and Sandia National Labs.[112]
Capacity
[
edit
]
Storage capacity is the amount of energy extracted from an energy storage device or system; usually measured in joules or kilowatt-hours and their multiples, it may be given in number of hours of electricity production at power plant nameplate capacity; when storage is of primary type (i.e., thermal or pumped-water), output is sourced only with the power plant embedded storage system.[113][114]
Economics
[
edit
]
The economics of energy storage strictly depends on the reserve service requested, and several uncertainty factors affect the profitability of energy storage. Therefore, not every storage method is technically and economically suitable for the storage of several MWh, and the optimal size of the energy storage is market and location dependent.[115]
Moreover, ESS are affected by several risks, e.g.:[116]
Therefore, traditional techniques based on deterministic Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) for the investment appraisal are not fully adequate to evaluate these risks and uncertainties and the investor's flexibility to deal with them. Hence, the literature recommends to assess the value of risks and uncertainties through the Real Option Analysis (ROA), which is a valuable method in uncertain contexts.[116]
The economic valuation of large-scale applications (including pumped hydro storage and compressed air) considers benefits including: curtailment avoidance, grid congestion avoidance, price arbitrage and carbon-free energy delivery.[101][117][118] In one technical assessment by the Carnegie Mellon Electricity Industry Centre, economic goals could be met using batteries if their capital cost was $30 to $50 per kilowatt-hour.[101]
A metric of energy efficiency of storage is energy storage on energy invested (ESOI), which is the amount of energy that can be stored by a technology, divided by the amount of energy required to build that technology. The higher the ESOI, the better the storage technology is energetically. For lithium-ion batteries this is around 10, and for lead acid batteries it is about 2. Other forms of storage such as pumped hydroelectric storage generally have higher ESOI, such as 210.[119]
Pumped-storage hydroelectricity is by far the largest storage technology used globally.[120] However, the usage of conventional pumped-hydro storage is limited because it requires terrain with elevation differences and also has a very high land use for relatively small power.[121] In locations without suitable natural geography, underground pumped-hydro storage could also be used.[122] High costs and limited life still make batteries a "weak substitute" for dispatchable power sources, and are unable to cover for variable renewable power gaps lasting for days, weeks or months. In grid models with high VRE share, the excessive cost of storage tends to dominate the costs of the whole grid — for example, in California alone 80% share of VRE would require 9.6 TWh of storage but 100% would require 36.3 TWh. As of 2018 the state only had 150 GWh of storage, primarily in pumped storage and a small fraction in batteries. According to another study, supplying 80% of US demand from VRE would require a smart grid covering the whole country or battery storage capable to supply the whole system for 12 hours, both at cost estimated at $2.5 trillion.[123][124] Similarly, several studies have found that relying only on VRE and energy storage would cost about 30-50% more than a comparable system that combines VRE with nuclear plants or plants with carbon capture and storage instead of energy storage.[125][126]
Research
[
edit
]
Germany
[
edit
]
In 2013, the German government allocated €200M (approximately US$270M) for research, and another €50M to subsidize battery storage in residential rooftop solar panels, according to a representative of the German Energy Storage Association.[127]
Siemens AG commissioned a production-research plant to open in 2015 at the Zentrum für Sonnenenergie und Wasserstoff (ZSW, the German Center for Solar Energy and Hydrogen Research in the State of Baden-Württemberg), a university/industry collaboration in Stuttgart, Ulm and Widderstall, staffed by approximately 350 scientists, researchers, engineers, and technicians. The plant develops new near-production manufacturing materials and processes (NPMM&P) using a computerized Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition (SCADA) system. It aims to enable the expansion of rechargeable battery production with increased quality and lower cost.[128][129]
United States
[
edit
]
In 2014, research and test centers opened to evaluate energy storage technologies. Among them was the Advanced Systems Test Laboratory at the University of Wisconsin at Madison in Wisconsin State, which partnered with battery manufacturer Johnson Controls.[130] The laboratory was created as part of the university's newly opened Wisconsin Energy Institute. Their goals include the evaluation of state-of-the-art and next generation electric vehicle batteries, including their use as grid supplements.[130]
The State of New York unveiled its New York Battery and Energy Storage Technology (NY-BEST) Test and Commercialization Center at Eastman Business Park in Rochester, New York, at a cost of $23 million for its almost 1,700 m2 laboratory. The center includes the Center for Future Energy Systems, a collaboration between Cornell University of Ithaca, New York and the Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute in Troy, New York. NY-BEST tests, validates and independently certifies diverse forms of energy storage intended for commercial use.[131]
On September 27, 2017, Senators Al Franken of Minnesota and Martin Heinrich of New Mexico introduced Advancing Grid Storage Act (AGSA), which would devote more than $1 billion in research, technical assistance and grants to encourage energy storage in the United States.[132]
In grid models with high VRE share, the excessive cost of storage tends to dominate the costs of the whole grid — for example, in California alone 80% share of VRE would require 9.6 TWh of storage but 100% would require 36.3 TWh. According to another study, supplying 80% of US demand from VRE would require a smart grid covering the whole country or battery storage capable to supply the whole system for 12 hours, both at cost estimated at $2.5 trillion.[123][124]
United Kingdom
[
edit
]
In the United Kingdom, some 14 industry and government agencies allied with seven British universities in May 2014 to create the SUPERGEN Energy Storage Hub in order to assist in the coordination of energy storage technology research and development.[133][134]
See also
[
edit
]
References
[
edit
]
Further reading
[
edit
]
Journals and papers
Books
5 ways of energy storage and how effective they are with regard to energy losses.
Energy sector’s future has always been associated with the fact that humanity will learn to accumulate energy effectively and to use it as necessary. The future is coming more confidently now and with different efficiency.
The efficiency of accumulating technologies is determined by the ratio of useful energy used to the total amount of energy received by the system. In other words, the efficiency of the batteries is evaluated in terms of energy losses during storage compared to the total amount of energy that was “poured into the system”.
Interestingly, that the assessment of batteries efficiency is often carried out in comparison with an external combustion engine, which has an efficiency of 23%, according to common data. In most cases, according to official information, of course, all energy storage systems show efficiency factors significantly higher than those of external combustion engines.
5 ways to store energy and how effective they are through the lens of “leaks”:
The most hyped type of energy storage. Thank you, Elon Musk. Energy storage in lithium-ion batteries is considered one of the most efficient. But for the time being, until the battery begins to degrade.
Pros: fast construction (Musk built the object in 100 days in Australia), almost instantaneous output of the stored energy to the network (tenths of a second).
Cons: price, degradation, disposal (its absence)
Tesla produces both domestic and industrial lithium-ion batteries (not to mention batteries for electric cars). And their efficiency under ideal conditions is approximately the same. But ideal conditions are rare.
The efficiency of the Tesla Powerwall inverter, a household battery, is 90%. This figure is indicated for the “complete cycle” of charging/discharging the battery: “alternating current to the battery and back to alternating current”, the specification for the battery says.
The performance measures of an industrial battery system, Tesla Powerpack, are about 88 - 89%.
If the capacity of one Powerpack is 210 kWh, then after one storage cycle, 186–187 kWh will be available for use back.
That’s if the battery is new and works at the optimum temperature. Storage system performance measures are indicated for operation at a temperature of 25 °C – too high or low temperatures damage the efficiency of a lithium-ion battery, although the specification states that they can operate at temperatures from -25 °C to + 50 °C.
Studies show that if the battery is fully charged for some (short) time at an ambient temperature of 40˚C, its capacity (the ability to store energy) will decrease by 35% in a year, even if it is used by small scale.
One of the main problems with lithium-ion systems is that they degrade over time. The degree of degradation depends on the intensity of the battery use – how often it worked during peak loads, how often it was discharged to zero. But on average, after ten years, the battery capacity decreases to “economically disadvantageous” levels (it applies to industrial facilities) – 50 - 70% of the declared for new batteries. Less capacity is less efficiency.
Degradation results another problem with lithium-ion batteries – their disposal.
Besides lithium-ion, there are batteries based on other metals. But their efficiency is slightly lower. As well as the cost. Below are data of researchers from China. The number of charging– discharging cycles, safety of use, energy density, cost and efficiency are described.
The cost of lithium-ion batteries (as of January 2018) is estimated at $213 - $640 per kWh, lead-carbon – $142 - $213 per kWh, vanadium flow batteries – $425 per kWh.
Pros: it is possible to supply methane directly to gas networks, container transportation
Cons: low efficiency, expensive electrolysis process
The logic is simple: excess electricity is used to produce hydrogen in the electrolysis process. Further, hydrogen can be converted to methane if there is a carbon source “nearby”. Gas is stored in special containers and output as needed. The efficiency of energy use is clearly shown below when renewable electricity is converted to hydrogen and then to methane.
The standard efficiency factor for such systems is about 50%.
Although scientists conduct researches in the field of high-temperature electrolysis and methanation, their efficiency exceeds 75%. Electrolysis at especially high temperatures around 800 °C is a significant advantage for increasing the efficiency of power-to-gas technology. We are waiting (or investing money in the technology).
Power-to-gas technology is the most efficient for long-term energy storage. With intraday charging-discharging losses are too large.
For example, the French company HDF Energy will build a solar park in French Guinea, within the framework of which there will be created hydrogen energy storage for long-term periods, but for short-term – lithium-ion batteries. The capacity of the solar park is going to be 55 MW, the capacity of a hydrogen storage battery –130 MWh, and the lithium-ion capacity – 10 MWh.
Pumped storage power plants are not as fresh as lithium-ion batteries or hydrogen storages. It has stood the test of decades, and it is the only accumulation technology used in Ukraine. Recently, it is being used too active, because after the launch of the market it is necessary to balance much more often.
Pros: inexpensive storage, high capacities
Cons: expensive and lengthy construction, the need for a suitable landscape
The data on the efficiency of the Tashlyk PSP
In the generator mode, the maximum efficiency is 87% (energy conversion efficiency while producing electricity in the process of draining water); in pumping mode (pumping water into the upper tank) – 90.8%. We emphasize – the maximum efficiency.
Commonly, the efficiency of the PSP is about 0.75, which means that out of every 100 kWh taken by the PSP from the system, 75 kWh is returned. And it applies to modern, more or less, technologies. If we are talking about PSPs built in the 60s, then the efficiency can be at the level of 40%.
Of course, it also depends on the size of the impoundment, its climatic location and other factors that affect the amount of water in the reservoir, which, among other things, affects the efficiency of the PSP.
The principle of work is based on gravity and friction, basically, it is similar to the PSP. But without water.
Pros: fast construction and comparative low cost
Cons: new technology with uncertain efficiency
The principle of work is based on gravity and friction, basically, it is similar to the PSP. But without water.
An interesting example of gravity storage was created by the American company (Advanced Rail Energy Storage North America) using the mini-railway in Nevada. Instead of pumping water into the upper tank when storing energy, the ARES project lifts carriages with ballast closer to the top of the hill; when energy is output, the carriages are lowered from the hill.
Each of the carriages is equipped with a 2 MW generator, when lifting it works like an electric motor, and on the descent it gives energy to the network. The efficiency of the entire system is estimated at 80 - 86%.
The difference in height between the points is 900 m (and this is a very large height difference, most PSPs do not have this), given that the length of the tracks along which the carriages move is 8 km. At its peak, the system output up to 50 MW of capacity. This is about 1.5 MW from each of 32 carriages (including all losses).
It is said that the launch of carriages on the move is very fast – from 5 to 10 seconds. This is not as good as with lithium-ion batteries, but in the area where the project was created, the inconsistencies of renewable energy sources are balanced mainly by gas thermal power plants, which are engaging for half an hour.
The ARES pilot experience was limited to tests at a distance of 240 m. In addition, critics insist that 80–86% efficiency is possible only with a short carriage path and the longer the descent and lift sections, the greater the loss.
Another no less interesting project works on the same gravitational principle – energy storage in a tower. The principle of operation – a six-star crane stands in the center, and concrete cylinders weighing 35 metric tons lie at a distance from it. When an excess of solar or wind electricity occurs, the electric engine is activated, and the crane, controlled by an automatic algorithm, lifts the concrete blocks one by one, folding them into a tower around its axis. The storage system is “fully charged” when the crane created a tower of concrete blocks around itself. The tower can store 20 MWh of energy. When there is a shortage of electricity in the network, the system starts in the opposite direction, and electricity is supplied to the network due to gravitational energy.
When the network runs at a low level, the engines come back into action – except that instead of consuming electricity, the engine is driven in reverse by gravitational energy and thus produce electricity.
This energy storage system was developed by the Swiss startup Energy Vault. The demonstration facility is located in Italy, near Milan.
Whereas concrete is much denser than water, lifting a concrete block requires (and therefore can store) much more energy than a reservoir of water of the same size, the developers note. The efficiency of such a system is about 85%.
Pros: inexpensive
Cons: Not very efficient, only suitable for seasonal energy storage
A couple of years ago, Siemens, which is actively developing wind power, proposed a solution for energy storage in Northern Germany. The excess energy produced by the wind farm is converted into heat, heats stones (up to 600 C), protected by an insulated cover. When there is a need for additional electricity, the steam turbine converts thermal energy back into electricity. This is the basic scheme of work of the energy storage “on hot stones”.
The project itself is inexpensive in the organization, but its effectiveness is still low. It is planned that a full-scale storage facility will be able to hold about 36 MWh of energy in a container with about 2000 cubic meters of the rock. Using a boiler, the accumulated heat can generate so much steam that the Siemens compact steam turbine can produce up to 1.5 MW of electricity up to 24 hours a day. In the early stages of development, the efficiency of the stone storage will be about 25%. In the future, the concept has an efficiency potential of about 50%. In other words, of the 36 MWh enter the storage, 18 MWh remains at the output.
Accumulation ways
Efficiency
Reaction
Expensive (+)/ inexpensive (-)
Durability
Mobility
Li-ion
88 – 90%
+
+
-
+
Power-to-gas
50%
+
+
+/-
+
PSP(new)
75%
-
-
+
-
Gravity storages
80 - 85%
-
-
+/-
+/-
Thermal storages
25% (it is promised to be 50%)
-
+/-
+
+/-
Kosatka.Media
39
0
0
Comments
All Comments (0)